Alastair is...

[kassidy62]

The Godfather, Marlon Brando in a Saw movie. Distracting.
Not speaking to the Anna got her grace thang. Or that they chased fallen stars over it. Crackity KER-akity CRACK.
NO HANDS ON THE MOIST WINDOW. Please.
Why chest close-ups? First Sam, now Dean. C'mon!!! Show it or no.
Nothing like the new Ruby to make me miss the old one. Except somehow she's growing on me - whether like a fungus or not, time will tell.
OH DEAN. You gave her up for Sam. Thank you for reminding us, show.
EDIT: Except it was planned? I need a rewatch. Hot alcoholic drinks and friends don't help ma conzentrayshun skillz and plot kung fu.
Huh? 
Doesn't matter - as Samida says, HE WOULD HAVE.

Comments

[veritykindle.livejournal.com]

I actually wondered if maybe Uriel forcing Dean to give Anna up for Sam was for real, and they only came up with the rest of the plan *after* that. Because the plan wouldn't have worked if they couldn't be sure of *both* sides being there, and would they really have been sure that they would have a way of getting the angels there at the right time? (Ruby *called* Alastair and tricked him into coming, but Uriel came to Dean by himself, which isn't something that they could have any control over.)

But maybe that's just me trying to rationalize it all away. ;)

[veritykindle.livejournal.com]

Well, the thing is, bringing the demons there on purpose makes no *sense* unless they could be sure the angels would be there, too. So, regardless of whether or not Dean knew about the plan when he gave Anna up to Uriel, *Sam* had to have known about the angels coming when he came up with the plan to get the demons there. And Dean clearly wasn't surprised that Ruby brought the demons, so I think he must have known about that part, too. So, what I'm imagining is that Dean gave Anna up because Uriel threatened Sam, but then he went to Sam and told him about it, and together, they agreed on the plan to bring the demons in, as well.

The only problem is that I'm having a *really* hard time imagining Dean going to Sam if he gave Anna up because of Sam without a backup plan. It just... doesn't seem to be in character for Dean to do that. So... I don't know. I'm not sure it completely makes sense, if you really think about it.